Carl Pickens Madden Career 1993-2000 - Peak 95 OVR
Carl Pickens Madden NFL 2000 rating

Carl Pickens Madden Career 1993-2000 - Peak 95 OVR

Position
WR
Team
Height
6'2"
Weight
206
College
Tennessee
DOB
Mar 23, 1970
Madden
1992-1999
93OVR
1999 Current
95OVR
Peak 1994
8
Seasons Played

Bengals receiver: 540 catches and the loyalty clause

Carl Pickens was born March 23, 1970 in Murphy, North Carolina, played at Tennessee, where he was a first-team All-American in 1991, and was drafted by the Cincinnati Bengals in the second round of 1992, 31st overall. He caught 26 passes and returned a punt 95 yards for a touchdown as a rookie, and was named Associated Press Offensive Rookie of the Year. Madden NFL 94 graded his 1993 season at a calculated 43.

He caught 71 passes for 1,127 yards in 1994, a season Madden NFL 95 put at a calculated 95. In 1995 he caught 99 passes for 1,234 yards and 17 touchdowns, tying Cris Carter for the NFL lead, and in 1996 he caught 100 for 1,180 yards. He made the Pro Bowl and Associated Press second-team All-Pro in both seasons, and Madden NFL 97 rated him 92 for 1996.

The Bengals later wrote a clause into his contract that forfeited bonus money if he publicly criticized the organization; an arbitrator upheld it in January 2001, and it became known as the Carl Pickens clause. He signed with Tennessee for 2000 and caught 10 passes for 242 yards, with Madden NFL 2001 listing him at 87. He signed with Dallas in April 2001 and retired the following month without playing a game there. Pickens finished with 540 receptions for 7,129 yards and 63 touchdowns in 129 games.

Carl Pickens Madden Career Milestones

  • Peak rating: 95 OVR (calculated) in Madden NFL 1995
  • Appeared in 8 Madden releases (Madden NFL 1993 through Madden NFL 2000)
  • Entered at 39 OVR in Madden NFL 1993, climbed 56 points to his peak
  • Biggest single-year rise: 52 points into Madden NFL 1995
  • Played for the Bengals across every Madden release in his career
  • Listed as a wide receiver in every Madden release
  • Final Madden appearance: Madden NFL 2000 at 93 OVR

Carl Pickens Madden Career Ratings

Scale (starred* rows) Only the starred 1-15-era seasons convert; modern rows stay 0-99.
Madden Team Pos OVR Speed ACC AGI STR JMP STA INJ AWR CAR BTK CTH TAK
1993 *
1992 NFL season
Bengals WR 39* 53 - 26 - - - - - 26 7 20 -
1994 *
1993 NFL season
Bengals WR 43* 53 - 33 - - - - - 33 7 33 -
1995 *
1994 NFL season
Bengals WR 95* 95 - 74 - - - - 90 95 16 58 -
1996 *
1995 NFL season
Bengals WR 82* 86 - 79 - - - - 46 66 13 79 -
1997
1996 NFL season
Bengals WR 92 90 76 84 - 64 74 - 87 34 10 93 7
1998 *
1997 NFL season
Bengals WR 92* 86 - 92 - - - - - 73 53 92 -
1999
1998 NFL season
Bengals WR 90* 83 85 89 57 - - 24 92 80 75 88 9
2000
1999 NFL season
Bengals WR 93* 93 92 93 57 - - 78 80 78 64 85 24
How to read these: Each row is the player’s rating in that year’s Madden, listed by the NFL season it covers (Madden NFL 2001 = the 2000 season). Madden sets its ratings before the season is played, so they reflect the previous season’s performance - a player’s breakout year tends to show up as a jump in the following year’s game.
About the starred rows*: Several early Madden releases rated players on a 1-15 scale, as printed in the game manuals, rather than the modern 0-99. We store those ratings converted to 0-99 (each manual point is about 6.6) so you can compare players across eras at a glance - use the 0-99 / 1-15 toggle above the table to see the original numbers on those seasons. EA didn’t publish an overall rating in those games, so the OVR* values for those years are our own calculation, the average of the player’s two best ratings.
Note: Some Madden releases tracked fewer attributes than others. Cells shown as - were not published by EA that year.

Carl Pickens Madden Ratings by Year

Carl Pickens Madden NFL 1993 rating: 39 OVR (1992 NFL season, CIN). Carl Pickens Madden NFL 1994 rating: 43 OVR (1993 NFL season, CIN). Carl Pickens Madden NFL 1995 rating: 95 OVR (1994 NFL season, CIN). Carl Pickens Madden NFL 1996 rating: 82 OVR (1995 NFL season, CIN). Carl Pickens Madden NFL 1997 rating: 92 OVR (1996 NFL season, CIN). Carl Pickens Madden NFL 1998 rating: 92 OVR (1997 NFL season, CIN). Carl Pickens Madden NFL 1999 rating: 90 OVR (1998 NFL season, CIN). Carl Pickens Madden NFL 2000 rating: 93 OVR (1999 NFL season, CIN).