Al Del Greco Madden Career 1994-2000 - Peak 95 OVR

Al Del Greco kicked in the NFL for 17 years, an Auburn product who went undrafted in 1984 and outlasted nearly everyone, finishing with 1,592 points, still among the top 25 scorers in league history. He bounced from Green Bay to the Cardinals before finding a long home with the Houston Oilers, who became the Tennessee Titans.

His best year came in 1998, when he earned his only Pro Bowl trip. Two seasons later he was the placekicker on the Titans team that reached Super Bowl XXXIV. He hit a field goal that tied the game at 16 in the second half, but Tennessee fell to the Rams 23-16, a yard short at the finish.

Del Greco shows up in these ratings as a study in a kicker's volatility. He was a 59 in the 1996 edition, a below-average leg by the game's math. Then comes the outlier, an 89 in the 2000 edition that reflected his Pro Bowl form, before the number collapsed back to 63 in 2001 as his career neared its close.