Peyton Hendershot Madden Career Madden NFL 2024 - Peak 67 OVR

Peyton Hendershot left Indiana as the school's most productive tight end ever, then went undrafted in 2022 and made the Cowboys on the strength of his hands. He carved out a depth and receiving role as a rookie, all seventeen games and a couple of touchdowns, a useful second-tier target behind the starters.

The Madden card is flat and fair, a 67 across Madden NFL 24 and 25, the grade of a backup tight end who catches a few and blocks when asked. The number never moved because the role never grew, an ankle injury cutting into his second year, just the steady low-70s rating that fits a depth piece exactly. There is no spike to chase and none to expect.

Dallas traded him to Kansas City in 2024, and he later drifted toward the UFL, the common path for an undrafted tight end who makes a roster but never locks down a starting job. Hendershot is honest depth, a player who did his small job well for a couple of years. The flat 67 is the right, unremarkable read on a receiving tight end who was exactly what he appeared to be.