Colt McCoy Madden Career 2011-2024 - Peak 77 OVR
Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2024 rating

Colt McCoy Madden Career 2011-2024 - Peak 77 OVR

Position
QB
Team
Cardinals
Height
6'1"
Weight
212
College
Texas
DOB
Sep 5, 1986
Madden
2010-2023
63OVR
2023 Current
77OVR
Peak 2011
14
Seasons Played

Colt McCoy Madden Career Ratings

Madden Team Pos OVR Speed ACC AGI COD STR JMP STA INJ TGH AWR PRC THP TAC TAS TAM TAD PAC TOR CAR TRK BCV SFA SPM JKM CTH SPC CIT SRR MRR DRR RLS RBK PBK IBL TAK POW PUR MCV ZCV PRS KPW KAC KRN
2011
2010 NFL season
 Browns QB 71 74 85 77 - 46 65 94 93 97 60 13 79 - 88 84 65 55 86 77 45 85 35 70 72 47 15 15 15 15 15 15 22 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2012
2011 NFL season
 Browns QB 77 74 85 77 - 46 - 94 93 97 73 - 80 86 88 85 67 61 86 77 45 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
2013
2012 NFL season
 Browns QB 75 74 83 78 - 46 65 94 93 97 74 13 81 - 86 76 63 63 84 77 45 85 35 70 72 47 15 15 15 15 15 15 22 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2014
2013 NFL season
 49ers QB 73 74 - 78 - 46 65 94 93 97 73 13 81 - 85 73 62 62 81 69 25 85 35 70 72 47 15 15 15 15 15 15 22 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2015
2014 NFL season
 Commanders QB 73 74 83 78 - 46 65 94 90 97 73 13 81 - 85 73 62 72 81 69 25 85 35 70 72 47 15 15 15 15 15 15 22 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2016
2015 NFL season
 Commanders QB 73 76 84 78 - 46 65 94 88 97 69 13 81 - 82 74 62 75 79 70 25 85 35 70 72 47 15 15 15 15 15 15 22 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2017
2016 NFL season
Did not play
 Commanders QB 68 75 84 78 - 46 65 94 88 97 70 13 81 - 83 77 73 75 78 70 25 85 35 70 72 47 15 15 15 15 15 15 22 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2018
2017 NFL season
 Commanders QB 67 77 85 81 - 46 65 94 88 97 71 13 81 - 83 76 72 75 78 70 25 85 35 74 72 47 15 15 15 15 15 15 22 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2019
2018 NFL season
 Commanders QB 65 76 85 81 - 46 65 94 88 85 71 13 81 - 83 76 72 75 78 70 25 85 35 74 72 47 15 15 15 - 13 15 17 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2020
2019 NFL season
 Commanders QB 62 75 84 81 - 46 65 94 88 85 75 13 77 - 85 76 73 76 75 67 25 82 36 72 69 47 15 15 15 - 13 15 17 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2021
2020 NFL season
 Giants QB 61 75 83 76 72 46 65 73 86 83 75 13 78 - 82 75 72 77 76 65 25 77 36 71 66 47 15 15 15 - 13 15 17 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2022
2021 NFL season
 Cardinals QB 61 74 83 75 71 46 65 73 86 83 74 13 78 - 82 75 73 77 76 65 25 76 36 65 66 47 15 15 15 15 13 15 17 18 27 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 32 10
2023
2022 NFL season
 Cardinals QB 62 73 77 72 67 45 65 73 86 83 70 13 81 - 84 75 73 77 76 64 25 75 36 63 66 47 15 15 15 - 13 15 17 18 26 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 30 10
2024
2023 NFL season
Did not play
 Cardinals QB 63 74 77 71 67 45 65 73 84 83 70 13 82 - 84 76 73 77 76 64 25 74 36 62 58 47 15 15 15 - 13 15 17 18 26 27 12 25 12 22 10 30 30 10
How to read these: Each row is the player’s rating in that year’s Madden, listed by the NFL season it covers (Madden NFL 2001 = the 2000 season). Madden sets its ratings before the season is played, so they reflect the previous season’s performance - a player’s breakout year tends to show up as a jump in the following year’s game.
Note: Some Madden releases tracked fewer attributes than others. Cells shown as - were not published by EA that year.

Colt McCoy Madden Career Milestones

  • Peak rating: 77 OVR in Madden NFL 2012 (age 25)
  • Appeared in 14 Madden releases (Madden NFL 2011 through Madden NFL 2024)
  • Played for 5 franchises: Browns, 49ers, Commanders, Giants, Cardinals
  • Listed as a quarterback in every Madden release

Era quarterbacks who played alongside Colt McCoy

Peyton Manning Madden ratings
Peyton Manning
Madden NFL 2012 - Colts
98
 Andrew Luck Madden ratings
Andrew Luck
Madden NFL 2018-2020 - Colts
92
 Deshaun Watson Madden ratings
Deshaun Watson
Madden NFL 2022-2026 - Browns
90
 Sam Bradford Madden ratings
Sam Bradford
Madden NFL 2015 - Rams
85
 Todd Collins Madden ratings
Todd Collins
Madden NFL 2007-2012
85
 Ryan Tannehill Madden ratings
Ryan Tannehill
Madden NFL 2018 - Dolphins
83
 David Garrard Madden ratings
David Garrard
Madden NFL 2012
83
 Chris Redman Madden ratings
Chris Redman
Madden NFL 2005-2013 - Falcons
82

Colt McCoy Madden Ratings by Year

Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2011 rating: 71 OVR (2010 NFL season, CLE). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2012 rating: 77 OVR (2011 NFL season, CLE). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2013 rating: 75 OVR (2012 NFL season, CLE). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2014 rating: 73 OVR (2013 NFL season, SF). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2015 rating: 73 OVR (2014 NFL season, WSH). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2016 rating: 73 OVR (2015 NFL season, WSH). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2017 rating: 68 OVR (2016 NFL season, WSH). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2018 rating: 67 OVR (2017 NFL season, WSH). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2019 rating: 65 OVR (2018 NFL season, WSH). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2020 rating: 62 OVR (2019 NFL season, WSH). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2021 rating: 61 OVR (2020 NFL season, NYG). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2022 rating: 61 OVR (2021 NFL season, ARI). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2023 rating: 62 OVR (2022 NFL season, ARI). Colt McCoy Madden NFL 2024 rating: 63 OVR (2023 NFL season, ARI).