Scouting Report: Weaknesses

• Ball security remains a glaring concern with 11 interceptions and multiple fumbles highlighting his tendency to make dangerous decisions under pressure.
• Processing speed lags behind elite college quarterbacks, often holding the ball too long when his first read isn't immediately available.
• Completion percentage of 59% reflects struggles with short and intermediate precision passing, particularly on timing routes that require anticipation and rhythm.
• Pocket presence needs refinement as he sometimes abandons clean pockets prematurely rather than stepping up and delivering from the hash marks.
• Inconsistent footwork mechanics that affect his accuracy, especially when throwing across his body or off his back foot during scramble situations.

Scouting Report: Summary

Aidan Chiles is a quarterback caught between two worlds - one where his rushing ability and explosive arm create highlight-reel moments, and another where processing delays and ball security lapses expose his developmental gaps. Chiles thrives when given clean looks and time to survey the field, unleashing deep strikes with impressive velocity and touch. Yet those same sequences often deteriorate when pressure arrives, forcing hurried decisions that result in dangerous throws into coverage. His mobility serves as both blessing and curse, extending plays that showcase his athleticism while occasionally masking his reluctance to work through progressions from the pocket.

The intermediate passing game presents the most telling contradiction in his skill set. While he can thread needles on comeback routes when his feet are set, his timing on crossing patterns and over routes remains inconsistent, leading to passes that arrive late or sail high. This hesitation in the short-to-medium range contrasts sharply with his confidence attacking vertically, where his natural arm strength allows him to challenge safeties and beat press coverage.

His junior season will ultimately determine whether he develops into a legitimate starter or remains a developmental backup with special package utility. The physical framework exists for NFL success, but quarterbacks who fail to improve their processing speed and decision-making typically plateau as change-of-pace options rather than franchise cornerstones. Chiles possesses enough raw talent to warrant mid-round consideration if he demonstrates consistent growth, though continued struggles with ball security and completion percentage could push him toward the late rounds regardless of his athletic upside. The tape shows flashes of Sunday-level ability, but sustained excellence requires the mental refinement that has eluded him thus far.