Ty Simpson QB Alabama |
NFL Draft Profile & Scouting Report

Scouting Report: Weaknesses

• Average build at 6-1, 211, with short arms that fall below NFL quarterback thresholds.
• Arm strength is more functional than special; limits some tight-window throws.
• Ball placement is inconsistent and leaves yards after catch on the field.
• Moves off reads faster than he should and bails to the checkdown early.
• Lost confidence as the 2025 season wore on and stopped pulling the trigger.
• Holds the ball too long in traffic; took bad sacks and fumbled seven times.
• Just 15 career starts; inexperience shows in read efficiency and situational feel.

Scouting Report: Summary

Simpson is an operator first. The three years he spent behind Bryce Young and Jalen Milroe show up in how he handles the pre-snap picture, how he communicates protection adjustments, and how quickly he gets through a progression once the ball is out. The mechanics are clean, the release is on time, and he has enough athletic ability to keep defenses honest on boots and naked keepers. None of that is in question.

The physical profile is what pushes him out of the top tier. He measured 6-1 with sub-31-inch arms and average hand size, and the arm strength on tape is good rather than special. He can make every NFL throw, but he cannot always make them late, and on the deep comeback and out-breaking concepts the ball arrives with less juice than evaluators want to see. That matters when the margin for error shrinks at the next level.

The 2025 season told two different stories. Through nine games he was one of the more efficient passers in the country, and Alabama worked through the meat of its SEC schedule with him playing clean, on-time football. Once opposing staffs built a book on him, his rhythm broke down, the aggressive throws disappeared, and the ball on the ground became a pattern rather than a blip. Some of that is a first-year starter adjusting to how the game changes when defenses know what you like. The supporting cast around him was part of it too, with 30 drops from his pass catchers in 2025. But the back half of the year is real, and any projection has to sit with it.

The fit is a team that can sit him behind a veteran for a year and let him acclimate without being asked to carry an offense from Week 1. He has the intangibles, the work habits, and the processing ability to be a quality NFL starter. The ceiling is a solid mid-tier starter who wins with command and timing. The floor is a long-term backup whose physical limits keep him from stringing together consistent starts. Patience from the coaching staff will decide which side he lands on.