Scouting Report: Weaknesses

• Release package lacks discipline and consistency – shows occasional quick-twitch ability but relies more on athletic advantages than technical skill to win early in routes.
• Route breaks telegraph intentions too early – rises up before cutting and lacks the sharp plant-and-drive footwork that would create greater separation.
• Hands show concerning inconsistency – alternates spectacular highlight grabs with routine drops, concentration seems to waver when anticipating contact.
• Struggles maintaining route integrity against physical corners – gets knocked off his landmarks too easily, leading to timing disruptions with quarterbacks.
• Long-strider who builds speed gradually – tested 4.65 in the forty isn't misleading, as he needs runway to reach top gear which limits his separation potential.
• Chose to not run at the combine - raises a red-flag over speed concerns

Scouting Report: Summary

When evaluating Brooks, the film shows both promise and limitations that explain his mid-to-late round consideration. His 4.65 deep speed raises legitimate concerns for his vertical game, yet his intermediate-to-deep receiving grades tell a different story. Brooks compensates through excellent body positioning and ball-tracking skills, finding ways to win despite athletic limitations. When watching his Louisville film, you see flashes of downfield playmaking mixed with technical inconsistencies that will limit his immediate impact.

What Brooks lacks in pure separation speed, he balances with functional versatility. His special teams background at Alabama – particularly as a punt blocker – provides immediate roster value while his receiving skills develop. The shoulder injury history merits thorough medical evaluation, but his bounce-back production at Louisville suggests durability. His developmental timeline remains a question, as a fourth-year college player still working through fundamentals that should be more refined at this stage.

The NFL transition will challenge Brooks in ways college defenses couldn't expose. His contested catch ability and scoring instinct will translate in specific situations, but his separation limitations will be magnified against NFL corners. He's neither a pure possession receiver nor a true deep threat – instead occupying a challenging middle ground that requires schematic assistance. With proper coaching focused on route precision and release techniques, Brooks could outperform his draft position as a complementary piece. His ceiling appears capped by athletic limitations, but his floor is raised by special teams value and situational receiving utility that could earn him a steady NFL role.