Scouting Report: Weaknesses

• Concerning frame at 175 pounds raises legitimate questions about his ability to withstand the physical punishment of every-down NFL carries.
• Pass protection remains a significant weakness, showing hesitancy and poor technique when asked to pick up blitzing linebackers and defensive backs.
• Limited power between the tackles makes him vulnerable in short-yardage situations where teams need guaranteed yards rather than explosive plays.
• Injury history at Western Carolina and missed games at Pittsburgh create durability concerns that NFL teams will scrutinize heavily during medical evaluations.
• Inconsistent ball security in traffic, with a tendency to carry the ball loosely when navigating through heavy contact in the secondary.

Scouting Report: Summary

Reid's future hinges on how NFL teams value explosive playmaking ability versus traditional every-down reliability. His electric receiving skills and game-breaking speed create a ceiling that few backs in this class can match, but his inability to handle pass protection assignments severely limits his three-down potential. The beauty of Reid's game lies in his versatility - he can line up anywhere and create immediate mismatches - yet that same 175-pound frame that allows such agility raises questions about surviving the rigors of a full NFL season.

What makes Reid intriguing is how his skill set aligns with league trends toward specialized roles and committee backfields. His return ability provides immediate value and multiple paths to the field, while his receiving prowess offers offensive coordinators a legitimate weapon in space. However, teams will need to scheme around his limitations, particularly in short-yardage situations where his lack of power becomes glaring. The injury history that limited him at Western Carolina and cost him games at Pittsburgh cannot be ignored when projecting his professional durability.

Reid's draft stock will ultimately depend on how teams weigh his explosive upside against his obvious limitations. His tape shows a player who can change games with his feet and hands, but also one who struggles with the physical demands of traditional running back responsibilities. The smart money says he lands somewhere in the middle rounds, where teams can afford to take a chance on his game-breaking ability while understanding the developmental timeline required to maximize his unique skill set. His path to NFL success runs through proving that his college production translates to a league where every defender is faster and stronger.